Header graphic for print
Class Action Blog Tp provide current legal information relating to class action lawsuits, including consumer fraud, consumer protection, securities and antitrust class actions

Are Penny Auctions A Scam?

Penny auctions are a new introduction to the Internet, and are proliferating.  The most popular ones are www.beezid.com, www.bidsauce.com, www.quibids.com, www.bidrivals.com, and www.dealdash.com.  A penny auction is nothing like eBay.  Users do not post the auction items for sale, but rather the owner and operator of the auction site is selling the items.  The items sold on penny auctions are usually high end electronic items like laptop computers, iPads or digital cameras.  But the main difference between a penny auction and eBay is that bidding at a penny auction is not free.  Here’s how it works.

Bidding at a penny auction is not free. You need to buy a package of bids, which can often cost as much as one dollar per bid (depending on the particular auction site you use). What this means is that each time you make a bid, you spend one dollar. This is completely different than eBay, where you can bid for free and only have to pay money if you are the winning bidder.

The price that the operator of penny auction sites offers for an item usually starts at $0 or $.01. Each bid (again, which can cost up to one dollar depending on the particular penny auction site you are using) bumps up the price of the item for sale by a penny or two. It also adds a certain amount of seconds to a countdown clock which times the bidding. Even if you are the winning bidder, you have not won the item itself, but simply have won the right to purchase the item at a final price set by the operator of the penny auction site. As an example, if you are bidding on an iPad which has a $50 final price attached to it, and you have placed 200 bids that cost one dollar each, if you win the bid and therefore the right to purchase the item at the final price attached to it, you will have paid $250 for the iPad.

 

There are allegations made by some users of penny auction sites that winners of bids often find it very difficult to get the item that they have purchased. Many times, the winning bidders are forced to wait weeks in order to get their items, and in some cases the penny auction websites simply close down without notice, thereby causing the bidders to not only lose the money that they have paid to purchase the bids, but also causing many members to not receive items that they purchased.

 

Penny auctions are a lot like gambling. Every bid you make costs you money, unlike a traditional auction where you only pay if you win. In penny auctions, consumers spend money on bids with the hope of winning a prize, the prize being simply the opportunity to purchase the item at a discount. But as is true with traditional gambling, the vast majority of the bidders who use penny auction sites lose money – the total amount of money people pay for the bids that are used to bid added together with the price of the item often exceeds the value of the item itself. Furthermore, many of the penny auction sites have “automatic” bidding programs where the customers can have the auction site bid for them: the automatic bidding programs can be designed to place bids for the customers at specific time when there is no chance of winning, thereby wasting the bid altogether. 

 

If you or someone you know has been deceived by a penny auction, please contact us to discuss your legal rights.

  • http://www.happybidday.com Dina Movshovitz

    The first time I joined a site like this, paid initial $85.00 for a bid package received “extra bids bonuses” and in the middle of biding 1 Cent auction for a camera i was told I am out of bids had to purchase extra $40.00 -The camera ended up costing me $125.00. At the auction I won the bidding at: 1.97 + 9.99 shipping fees that I had to pay for separately.
    I e mailed the site they promised to return an e mail within 2 days. I think I will call my Visa and refuse the charges.
    Dina Movshovitz

  • http://www.pennygrab.com/ Penny Auctions

    The best thing regarding penny auctions, except the truth that one could obtain some truly costly objects for mere pocket change, is that it is cool to do. It is like playing a game, apart from that you can walk away with genuine items that you need or want as a substitute of racking up points on a scoreboard.

  • http://www.quibids.com/ Martin Barr-David

    http://www.quibids.com/ had an advert on late night tv, I thought I’ll give it ago and they ask for AUD$70 when I read some complaints from MyWOT.COM WHwhich gave it bad recommendation I quickly cancelled my account after they charged me 1c because I had insufficient funds.

  • JB

    The consumer should always be cautious regardless of where they spend their money. The penny auction site I frequent has a “Buy it now” option which is a great way to save yourself from OVERSPENDING on any item. It works the best when someone goes in looking to purchase the item and is not opposed to paying retail should that become necessary and ALL BIDS placed by the bidder on that item apply to the retail cost. So once again we should not feel as though we need to control anyones spending habits if there is a reasonable exit strategy provided them.

  • anelli

    I ran into this site called duelingbids.com and made the dumb, idiotic decision to purchase 3 bid packs at a little over $5 each without studying the site and doing my homework and I got deservedly burned. After making the expenditure, I realized that I never encountered any opposition when bidding for the bid packs. I then (after the fact) decided to observe the site and I realized that the same user names were”winning” auctions for high-end electronics such as Apple iPads and iPods, Kindles etc. with 1 or 2 bids. I then checked the hard to find “ended auctions” and I saw more of the same: the same user names “winning” auctions with 1 or 2 bids over and over and over again. By the time I had taken all this in, I knew for a fact that I had stupidly allowed myself to be scammed of $15 dollars. Needless to say, I didn’t win the iPod I went for as two shills who kept bidding against me–and never against each other–made sure of that. I forgot to mention that the site gives you 100 free bids to join and I think that is what blinded and stupefied me. Greed. But then again, one hundred free bids without any catch is too good to be true. I should have seen that.

  • http://www.9zilla.com looking for anti scam auction site

    out browsing the web looking for auction sites that arent scams and found your blog. nice stuff keep it up.

  • http://www.theweepingprophet.com Kelly Fritz

    While there are many penny auction sites that are not designed well and have terrible customer support, there are some who are legitimate business operations. For example, I like BidCactus. It has delivered on over 350,000 winners since it was founded in 2009 and they even have auctions to raise funds for charities. It is definitely a “buyer-beware” industry. Best advise is to spend some time looking through trusted review sites before you go out and signup for something. Always best to make an informed decision. :o)

  • http://twitter.com/nyctreeman nyctreeman

    they are all scams and should be illegal.
    even the ones that dutifully deliver the item to the winner are scams.
    they really are no different than on-line gambling, in that a person cannot possibly “win” an auction by positively outbidding the next highest bidder, rather the person who wins does so by sheer chance, if in fact the so-called winner is not a shill of the company running the auctions.

    for those companies that actually do deliver the item, they are essentially running a game of chance, much like a progressive version of a raffle, in which participants not only enter the raffle, but can enhance their chances by purchasing more tickets. (as it were).

    the essential part of this scam is, that the items are not really being auctioned off in the true sense of the word, and the enormous profits being made are not on the sale of the item, but on the sale of chances, or so-called bids, and in which case is only a matter of semantics.

    it’s a brilliant scam, and I’m not saying people don’t realize great wins, but the fact of the matter is, this is really a sophisticated raffle system where the people running have merely replaced the words “chances” or “tickets” with the word “bids”, and like any raffle, you must purchase the  ticket or chance.

    running raffles is illegal for persons other than charities, and these phony auctions should be illegal as well, IMO